Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - topcat1019

Pages: [1]
1
Flat Earth Investigations / Re: Antipodal journeys
« on: November 06, 2018, 02:47:04 PM »
Robinofloxley:

Thanks for the detailed flight info, but I'll clarify my question. What is the straight line distance between Buenos Aires and Cape Town? On a globe it would roughly be the same distance as Chicago to Barcelona.  But on a flat map it would be 2.5x further. Also, if I read a flat map correctly, taking a straight line trip from Buenos Aires to Cape Town would require flying northeast essentially along the entire east coast of South America, where on a globe it would be over open ocean the entire trip. So which is it? This seems a fairly easy question to prove. I'm less interested in what commercial flights actually do and more interested in how to prove globe vs flat. Skipping the great circle routes, it seems a simple test would be taking off from two cities mentioned, and flying due east along each latitude at same speed toward each destination. Globe model says they'll reach their destinations, FE theory says they won't.

I'm including a graphic to show that a globe trip would require travel due east, over open ocean, while FE model indicates northeast travel over land - the east coast of South America. Again, seems like a simple way to prove which is correct. I also marked the distance on a flat map of Chicago to Barcelona, which is quite shorter than Buenos Aires to Cape Town on a flat map.

2
Flat Earth Investigations / Re: Antipodal journeys
« on: November 05, 2018, 04:45:17 PM »
To add to that, can someone answer this travel question: What's the distance from Chicago to Barcelona? and what's the distance from Buenos Aires to Cape Town, South Africa?

Here's why:
Traveling by airplane from Chicago to Barcelona on a globe is measured at about 4,400 miles. Traveling from Buenos Aires to Capetown is about the same distance (4,200 miles). Flying from Chicago to Barcelona would stay entirely along the 42° n latitude (exactly straight ahead; never turning the airplane), and Buenos Air/Capetown trip would remain entirely along the 34° south latitude (also never turning). If 2 planes take off at the same time, they should both arrive at their destinations at the same time. However, I haven't seen detailed flat earth maps, but it looks like the Buenos Aires trip should be 2.5x longer distance. Also, you would have to keep the airplane turning along a curve, rather than straight ahead. Have either of these been measured and proven? Seems like an easy way to prove the flat map once and for all.

Pages: [1]