The Flat Earth Society

Other Discussion Boards => Arts & Entertainment => Topic started by: junker on April 12, 2019, 07:10:28 PM

Title: Episode IX
Post by: junker on April 12, 2019, 07:10:28 PM
I just watched the trailer. I think I have forgotten everything that has happened up to this point. The trailer didn't make a lot of sense.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Cain on April 12, 2019, 08:18:49 PM
Looks ok I guess.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Fortuna on April 12, 2019, 11:49:00 PM
Not hyped at all. The sequels are a narrative mess.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Snupes on April 13, 2019, 01:45:08 AM
The name is horrible. And J.J. Abrams is directing. Not a good sign, any.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: honk on April 13, 2019, 04:07:05 AM
Okay, I guess I'll be the one to post it:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=adzYW5DZoWs

It is just a teaser, to be fair. But I have questions. What the hell is up with that title? It sounds awkward and clunky, and the Skywalkers have already been directly or indirectly the focus of pretty much the entire film series up until now. There's nothing for them to "rise" to. They have already risen. They should be declining at this point. Let the franchise be about other things already. Move on. I'm worried that this is going to lead into some dumb twist about one or more characters turning out to be Skywalkers all along, which wouldn't have been a concern of mine if not for the fact that Abrams is at the helm. He's not a bad director, but it's impossible to ignore his weakness for pandering, fanservice, and prioritizing crowd-pleasing spectacle over substantive story. For better or worse, TLJ took the series to new ground, something that ought to be explored further, and I feel like Abrams is the kind of guy who'd look at that and see something to be course-corrected. Palpatine laughing at the end especially rubs me the wrong way. If it's a flashback or a recording or something, fine, but he had better not turn out to be still alive or show up as a clone or whatever.

It could be worse, though. They could have let Colin Trevorrow direct as originally planned.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: junker on April 13, 2019, 09:34:14 PM
So much for leaving the past in the past. What a meme
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Bastian Baasch on April 13, 2019, 11:30:47 PM
\ Palpatine laughing at the end especially rubs me the wrong way. If it's a flashback or a recording or something, fine, but he had better not turn out to be still alive or show up as a clone or whatever.

Oof, looks like he's really back.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/markhughes/2019/04/12/j-j-abrams-confirms-emperor-returns-in-star-wars-the-rise-of-skywalker/ (https://www.forbes.com/sites/markhughes/2019/04/12/j-j-abrams-confirms-emperor-returns-in-star-wars-the-rise-of-skywalker/)
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rama Set on April 14, 2019, 01:33:35 AM
JJ tryin to fix all the dumb shit that happened in Ep 8 and do service to the fan boys while adding a twist. Bound to be shit.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Lord Dave on April 14, 2019, 10:04:22 AM
Eh, if Yoda, Ben, and Anakin can be force ghosts, why not Palpatine? 

Also, remember that Anakin Skywalker was the son of a slave mother and a daddy who didn't exist or was the force so who knows on that.  Rey could be related distsntly or something to Luke. My grandfather was Anakin's half-brother kinda thing.

Or Skywalker is just a title given to the one who brings balance to the force. 

But, looks good so far, aside from the giant "RotJ" vibe.  Guess JJ is just gonna remake it.  Like he did with force awakens.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rama Set on April 14, 2019, 01:52:17 PM
Ben Solo is also half skywalker.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: honk on April 16, 2019, 04:17:52 AM
Eh, if Yoda, Ben, and Anakin can be force ghosts, why not Palpatine? 

Also, remember that Anakin Skywalker was the son of a slave mother and a daddy who didn't exist or was the force so who knows on that.  Rey could be related distsntly or something to Luke. My grandfather was Anakin's half-brother kinda thing.

I enjoy discussing lore lore lore as much as the next person, but pointing to canon is not a justification for poor artistic decisions. Palpatine shouldn't return because as a character, he is done and dusted. He was the overarching villain of the first six movies, and now he's all played out. We saw his rise, we saw him at his prime, we saw his defeat in a strong cathartic moment, and that's all we need. The current saga is doing just fine with Kylo as the new main villain - someone who is nothing like Palpatine and has a very different dynamic with the hero. It's good to be doing something different. We don't need to see Abrams give us something that the first three movies have already done better.

Regarding the relations, I'll need to assume a bit about what's coming up, but we've already had six movies emphasizing the importance of prophecy, destiny, and heredity. TLJ established Rey as someone who genuinely came from nothing and was ready to make her own destiny. That's different, and it's good that it's different. There's no reason to go back to doing what the first trilogy already did when there's no chance of doing it better.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Lord Dave on April 16, 2019, 06:22:50 AM
Eh, if Yoda, Ben, and Anakin can be force ghosts, why not Palpatine? 

Also, remember that Anakin Skywalker was the son of a slave mother and a daddy who didn't exist or was the force so who knows on that.  Rey could be related distsntly or something to Luke. My grandfather was Anakin's half-brother kinda thing.

I enjoy discussing lore lore lore as much as the next person, but pointing to canon is not a justification for poor artistic decisions. Palpatine shouldn't return because as a character, he is done and dusted. He was the overarching villain of the first six movies, and now he's all played out. We saw his rise, we saw him at his prime, we saw his defeat in a strong cathartic moment, and that's all we need. The current saga is doing just fine with Kylo as the new main villain - someone who is nothing like Palpatine and has a very different dynamic with the hero. It's good to be doing something different. We don't need to see Abrams give us something that the first three movies have already done better.

Regarding the relations, I'll need to assume a bit about what's coming up, but we've already had six movies emphasizing the importance of prophecy, destiny, and heredity. TLJ established Rey as someone who genuinely came from nothing and making her own destiny. That's different, and it's good that it's different. There's no reason to go back to doing what the first trilogy already did when there's no chance of doing it better.

I don't disagree.  Kylo is a good main villian.  He's the evil Anakin we all would have wanted.  And Palpatine doesn't need to come back.  They can have him haunt the deathstar and show up as a creepy ghost just to be brushed aside and ignored, that woukd be fine.


Also:
RotS (Sith)
RotJ (Jedi)
RotS (Skywalker)
I see a pattern.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rama Set on April 16, 2019, 10:49:06 AM
Eh, if Yoda, Ben, and Anakin can be force ghosts, why not Palpatine? 

Also, remember that Anakin Skywalker was the son of a slave mother and a daddy who didn't exist or was the force so who knows on that.  Rey could be related distsntly or something to Luke. My grandfather was Anakin's half-brother kinda thing.

I enjoy discussing lore lore lore as much as the next person, but pointing to canon is not a justification for poor artistic decisions. Palpatine shouldn't return because as a character, he is done and dusted. He was the overarching villain of the first six movies, and now he's all played out. We saw his rise, we saw him at his prime, we saw his defeat in a strong cathartic moment, and that's all we need. The current saga is doing just fine with Kylo as the new main villain - someone who is nothing like Palpatine and has a very different dynamic with the hero. It's good to be doing something different. We don't need to see Abrams give us something that the first three movies have already done better.

Without knowing what they are doing the character you are just talking out of your ass.  I am dubious, but to say there is no world where the return of Palpatine doesn't work is just close-minded and over-reaching.

Quote
Regarding the relations, I'll need to assume a bit about what's coming up, but we've already had six movies emphasizing the importance of prophecy, destiny, and heredity. TLJ established Rey as someone who genuinely came from nothing and making her own destiny. That's different, and it's good that it's different. There's no reason to go back to doing what the first trilogy already did when there's no chance of doing it better.

The dark side told her she came from nothing.  We don't know if its the actual truth.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Snupes on April 16, 2019, 10:43:11 PM
Without knowing what they are doing the character you are just talking out of your ass.  I am dubious, but to say there is no world where the return of Palpatine doesn't work is just close-minded and over-reaching.

Such is the point of speculation. It's okay to speculate without tacking on "in my opinion" or "though it's potentially possible to do right maybe".

The dark side told her she came from nothing.  We don't know if its the actual truth.

I think it's best that she be of inconsequential parentage. The whole "chosen one" schtick is played out too much in this series, and having a character make their own destiny would be far more interesting at this point. In my opinion. Though it's potentially possible to do right maybe.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rushy on April 17, 2019, 03:12:57 AM
Rey's mother is Leia and her father is Luke.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Lord Dave on April 17, 2019, 09:51:11 AM
Rey's mother is Leia and her father is Luke.

Or or or...

Rey has no parents.  She spontaniously appeared from nothing.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rama Set on April 17, 2019, 03:33:43 PM
Without knowing what they are doing the character you are just talking out of your ass.  I am dubious, but to say there is no world where the return of Palpatine doesn't work is just close-minded and over-reaching.

Such is the point of speculation. It's okay to speculate without tacking on "in my opinion" or "though it's potentially possible to do right maybe".

I don’t know how “Palpatine shouldn’t return...” can be construed as speculation. It sounds more like his personal preference. If he only wants the movies to play out in a way that he thinks is correct, that’s cool for him.

Quote
The dark side told her she came from nothing.  We don't know if its the actual truth.

I think it's best that she be of inconsequential parentage. The whole "chosen one" schtick is played out too much in this series, and having a character make their own destiny would be far more interesting at this point. In my opinion. Though it's potentially possible to do right maybe.
I thought that was the most interesting part of the Last Jedi and Rey’s relationship with Kylo Ren: that he proposed a blank slate to her. No more destiny, no holding on to past forms. It could be a great way to introduce the idea of grey Jedi to canon.

Inb4 Rey is the child of midichlorians
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: honk on April 18, 2019, 02:10:14 AM
Without knowing what they are doing the character you are just talking out of your ass.  I am dubious, but to say there is no world where the return of Palpatine doesn't work is just close-minded and over-reaching.

Saying something "doesn't work" is vague. Rehashing Palpatine could be handled well and it could be handled poorly, but it remains a bad idea either way, and it's perfectly fair to criticize it for being a bad idea without knowing how well it'll be executed. It wouldn't change my mind on this. For example, Abrams sticking so closely to the storyline and character archetypes of ANH was easily TFA's biggest flaw, and yet I recognize that it was all executed about as well as it reasonably could have been. It was still a bad idea that the movie would have been better off without.

I don’t know how “Palpatine shouldn’t return...” can be construed as speculation. It sounds more like his personal preference. If he only wants the movies to play out in a way that he thinks is correct, that’s cool for him.

Yes. The opinions and preferences I am sharing in this thread are in fact my own.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rama Set on April 18, 2019, 02:34:51 PM
It’s not a bad idea, it’s an idea you don’t like. You not liking an idea says nothing about it’s value. Avenger: Infinity War managed to bring back Red Skull in an interesting way without overemphasizing him because he already had a complete journey. Something like that could work.

The journey in to the underworld is extremely fertile mythological ground and it would be not only simple but could also be effective to see the spirit of Palpatine in that context. If they try to have him actually come back as a living, corporeal creature I doubt it could work but the beauty of film making is that a lot of things can be imagined.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: WellRoundedIndividual on April 18, 2019, 02:50:25 PM
I wonder if they are going to do a Force Vision with Palpatine or whatever like Luke had with Vader in the swamps of Dagoba.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Lord Dave on April 18, 2019, 02:55:34 PM
It’s not a bad idea, it’s an idea you don’t like. You not liking an idea says nothing about it’s value. Avenger: Infinity War managed to bring back Red Skull in an interesting way without overemphasizing him because he already had a complete journey. Something like that could work.

The journey in to the underworld is extremely fertile mythological ground and it would be not only simple but could also be effective to see the spirit of Palpatine in that context. If they try to have him actually come back as a living, corporeal creature I doubt it could work but the beauty of film making is that a lot of things can be imagined.

In fairness, the red skull wasn't trumped up in the first (or any) teaser/trailer.  You usually do that for big characters, not a short cameo. Unless its a famous actor.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Rama Set on April 18, 2019, 03:14:03 PM
Yeah, just making the point that the reintroduction of a character who has already completed their arc isn’t a bad idea on its face.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: markjo on April 22, 2019, 06:03:16 PM
Inb4 Rey is the child of midichlorians
Twin sister from another mother?

I wonder if they are going to do a Force Vision with Palpatine or whatever like Luke had with Vader in the swamps of Dagoba.
I seem to recall a Star Wars spinoff comic by Dark Horse that had Palpatine return in cloned body.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Empire_I
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Baby Thork on April 22, 2019, 06:22:50 PM
Rey needs to ditch the storm trooper and get with the wookie. He's tall, strong, there's plenty to hang on to and he's a hero. Unlike the boring trooper. He'd also make a cool noise when he empties his nuts.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: beardo on April 22, 2019, 09:02:04 PM
Rey needs to ditch the storm trooper and get with the wookie. He's tall, strong, there's plenty to hang on to and he's a hero. Unlike the boring trooper. He'd also make a cool noise when he empties his nuts.
Racist.
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: markjo on April 22, 2019, 10:07:58 PM
Rey needs to ditch the storm trooper and get with the wookie. He's tall, strong, there's plenty to hang on to and he's a hero. Unlike the boring trooper. He'd also make a cool noise when he empties his nuts.
Too late, Chewie is already married.
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Mallatobuck
Title: Re: Episode IX
Post by: Cain on April 23, 2019, 12:17:24 PM
Rey needs to ditch the storm trooper and get with the wookie. He's tall, strong, there's plenty to hang on to and he's a hero. Unlike the boring trooper. He'd also make a cool noise when he empties his nuts.
Too late, Chewie is already married.
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Mallatobuck
She doesn't have to know.