Beardo, the question is kind of stupid, really. Ghost Spaghetti, as you are no doubt well aware, the Bible resolves that problem by saying we once lived in Paradise, and screwed it up. Now, you don't have to accept that. No one is trying to make you accept that, least of all me. But if you do not, you run into the whole issue of theodicy.
Why would G-d permit the crap to go on that does? If you don't answer the question in the Biblical way, and you are certainly free not to, then you have to answer it some other way. And how you interpret the Garden of Eden story, and Adam and Eve, and all that, is really up to you.