I'm simply demonstrating how flawed your generalizations are. If I'm grasping at straws, then so are you.
Your arguments represent a basic misunderstanding of mine, not a reflection.
Unfortunately, you wouldn't know that. Seeing as you haven't played the game, you have no idea what you're actually generalizing; I do, on the other hand, and I produced the most accurate equivalent argument for SotC that boils down criticisms in the exact same manner. Just like how to an outside observer SotC is just doing that same climbing section over and over again, Dark Souls is, er, I guess rolling and swiping. You know there's more to SotC than that, yet you're hellbent on assuming there isn't anything else to Dark Souls without confirming it yourself in any way, shape or form. You've just seen the fights without the "puzzles", so to speak.