Me
"Back to your version of god, that’s what it is, your version. What makes that right? It sounds just as full of mumbo jumbo as every other cult. Just to reiterate, I see no sign of a maker/greater being, no plan, no comforting presence guiding me. You show me the proof.
Freedom? I have it, no dogma or creed, no hope of redemption just the endless night, let me sleep."
Robo
I didn't give a version of God. I asked if it made sense that if God exists would we need a book of instructions. I questioned that it doesn't stand to reason that he would bless only a few.
So round and round we go. So give me your version of god whose proof is the existence of Love, on second thoughts don't.
You don't need a god for love to exist, so your argument has no weight. It has been explained how and why, if you can't get it, fine back to your navel gazing, there are plenty of you out there in your personal wildernesses berating those of us that have moved on, we can take it.
Fact:
Man seeks to love and be loved universally.
Fact:
Man is willing to die in the hope of saving a loved on.
Fact:
Man can survive without compassionate love.
Jura
"You don't need a god for love to exist"
This is not a fact, it is an opinion, you haven't proved it.
I gave you the hypothesis, you can disagree with my hypothesis but you have to justify the facts I presented.
essay:
formal
an attempt or effort.
"a misjudged essay"
synonyms: attempt, effort, endeavor, try, venture, trial, experiment, undertaking
"his first essay in telecommunications"
verbformal
eˈsā/
1.
attempt or try.
"essay a smile"
An essay written 25 years ago, not hardly.
You have to justify why man universally strongly seeks to love and be loved. and you have to justify why if man can survive without loving that he so desperately seeks it universally.
Jura:
"so your argument has no weight. It has been explained how and why, if you can't get it, fine back to your navel gazing, there are plenty of you out there in your personal wildernesses berating those of us that have moved on, we can take it."
The facts I outlined above have no weight? Then justify them.
I didn't berate you, I cited the fact that your certitude has closed your mind by your own admission that you believe unequivocally that God does not exist.
a prioiShow me that perspective is a product of an open mind.
"Jura:
you out there in your personal wildernesses berating those of us that have moved on, we can take it."
Now that's berating!
God has to "guide you"? Why?
R