21
Flat Earth Theory / Re: How do flat earthers explain travel with cardinal directions?
« on: May 03, 2017, 04:17:47 AM »
Maybe this will help
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Tom, please show me some objects that appear to be over horizon and are brought back over the horizon with greater magnification. In the video that I just posted the ship didn't rise up over the horizon when the magnification was increased. It just got bigger.I would like to see some cities that are over the horizon get restored through magnification.
Apparently you have not read Earth Not a Globe: http://sacred-texts.com/earth/za/za33.htm
What is its distance right now?What is the distance of the sun from the center?Tom, is the sun at the center of dish/plane?
No.
It depends on the time of the year.
What is the distance of the sun from the center?Tom, is the sun at the center of dish/plane?
No.
The only "hand off" perfectly straight courses are those that bisect the center of the earth. The only straight course with constant headings would be east/west at the equator or true north/south courses. Latitude constant courses other than the equator do not bisect the center of the earth. They cannot be followed "hand off". They require constant "hands on" to follow a heading because they are not straight paths. If latitude lines where straight "hand off" courses then aircraft would use them to fly from LA to Tokyo. They don't use that course because it's not a great circle route. The shortest straight line path goes up near Alaska. The latitude line isn't shorter because it's not "hands off" straight. It's actually curved. The challenge to "hands off" straight great circle routes is that they have constantly changing headings.You are wrong on this one. I believe the earth is round. I also know that the only place on a globe where you can travel a heading of true east or west and have it be a straight line is at the equator. Every other path with an east or west heading will result in a curved line.If it makes it easier, try imagining following a compass due east when you are just twenty feet from the north pole.
Did you travel in a straight line or in a circle?It's hardly a moot point from your position because the straight lines paths due east in the southern hemisphere in reality trend northward rather than southward.
That is an entirely different point from the one he was trying to make.
That's exactly my point. When you are 20 feet from the north pole the distance between you and the north pole is effectively flat and you see what would happen to your compass if the world was flat rather than round. Its only with curvature that compasses can actually perform like they do in real life. Its only with curvature that a compass will continue to point east if you travel in a straight line.
Yes, the line will be curved because the surface of the earth is curved but you won't have to constantly change course. You can effectively take your hands off the wheel and you will maintain a due east/west course. This kind of behavior is impossible on a flat earth. Sorry for the confusion, I was trying to simplify things for people who aren't familiar with navigation but I think I confused you in the process because you actually understand how travel over the earth actually occurs.
You are wrong on this one. I believe the earth is round. I also know that the only place on a globe where you can travel a heading of true east or west and have it be a straight line is at the equator. Every other path with an east or west heading will result in a curved line.If it makes it easier, try imagining following a compass due east when you are just twenty feet from the north pole.
Did you travel in a straight line or in a circle?It's hardly a moot point from your position because the straight lines paths due east in the southern hemisphere in reality trend northward rather than southward.
That is an entirely different point from the one he was trying to make.
That's exactly my point. When you are 20 feet from the north pole the distance between you and the north pole is effectively flat and you see what would happen to your compass if the world was flat rather than round. Its only with curvature that compasses can actually perform like they do in real life. Its only with curvature that a compass will continue to point east if you travel in a straight line.
Well, even on a round Earth, you're not really tracing a straight line when you go east, you're traveling in a circle. So it all seems like kind of a moot point.It's hardly a moot point from your position because the straight lines paths due east in the southern hemisphere in reality trend northward rather than southward.
See, east and west trace circles around the north pole while north and south trace circles that go through the north pole. So the cardinal directions are as follows: North is Hubwards, South is Rimwards, East is Turnwise, and West is Widdershins.
You won't go in a straight line though. You will follow a curved path called a rhumb line. A great circle route is a straight path but the heading will constantly change. It is quite possible to get from one location to another following a constant heading. It is not the shortest route though because it will following a curved path. The only place where a straight east or west path can be taken is at the equator. Take a look at Google Earth for experimentation. If you draw a straight path with a heading of 90° at 45 north latitude the line will trend south. Google Earth uses great circle routes to draw the straight lines.The same thing happens on a spherical earth except at the equator.
Sorry but you fail basic geometry there. If you are on a sphere and you circumscribe the sphere (which means traveling west-east or east-west on our planet) the top and bottom of the sphere (the poles) will always be perpendicular to the circumscribed route. If you don't believe me grab a ball or a balloon, draw a circle around that object, and then draw lines to the pole of the object.