Thor (Kenneth Branagh)
Actually kind of not bad at all, even pretty good at times. The whole thing does have the air of overgrown children in plastic suits playfighting in their backyard (never let it be said that Marvel does not know their audience), imagining fantastic worlds and creating stories about banishments, rescues, evil plots etc., but it's done with a certain spirit and vivacity that lifts it above the sort of film-by-committee style of Favreau's Iron Man. Branagh's camera style occasionally leaves something to be desired, falling over into sterotypical modern action territory with shaky handheld nonsense right from the get-go, in addition to some really awkward Dutch angles which he uses to show us... Natalie Portman looking pretty? Really, Ken? My main criticism however is that the over-reliance on CGI makes a lot of stuff look and feel terribly synthetic, and mostly what has stuck with me since finishing the film is questions like: how cool would the giant fire breathing robot have been as a practical effect using animatronics? And others the answers to which we may never know.
Character wise, Thor is actually a likeable hero. Not from the get-go, but he has an arc, and Chris Hemsworth plays him in a charming manner that reeks of valiant fairytale princes and knights, which is highly appropriate. I hate to keep bringing up Metal Guy, especially when I've already done it once earlier in the review, but the differences between the arcs of Thor and Tony Stark are quite interesting to compare. Stark's progression goes: rich asshole > rich asshole with a conscience > rich alcoholic asshole with a conscience; but Thor grows from an arrogant, warlike, power hungry manchild into a respectable, noble, and selfless defender of the people he comes to love. Obviously he has to change rather quickly in the time he has to spare, since there's nary a moment of the film's just under two hours that goes by without a pratfall, action sequence, or INTENSE ACTING!!! (not to mention one or two "Hulk claps out the flames" moments, such as the hammercopter technique), but it's handled rather well. Other performances I liked were Stellan SkarsgÄrd as Old Scientist of Unidentifiable Ethnicity, Anthony Hopkins as One Eyed Man with Loud Stick, and Idris Elba as Comically Segregated Black Dude. The female side of the cast is a little flimsy, not because of the actors but because they aren't really given much to do. For example, Natalie Portman's job is to look serious and say science-y things, then ogle Thor's muscles and act embarrassed when he catches her in the act. Jaimie Alexander as Sif is the major exception, but she is literally generic warrior maiden who spent her life trying to prove that she is just as strong as the men and what have you.
You can tell I liked this more than other MCU offerings so far because I have run on into a whole third little paragraph here. It's pretty good, and I feel like Branagh's involvement has helped with that, I don't wish to present a dichotomy between "serious filmmaking" and "mere entertainment," because that's just silly and unfair, but I do feel like his history with Shakespeare, and his understanding of fantasy, mythology, and how to direct action, helped keep this from being a stodgy and dull, and it was silly in good way, not in a "I want to find the address of the people who wrote this and punch them" way. The hammercopter thing will never not be really fucking stupid, however. So yeah, MCU confirmed for getting better over time, I guess, or at least I hope so.
Next time on 2015: A Capeshit Odyssey: Nazis with bad skin conditions.